The Best Unleaded Gas Prices from Cleveland, OH to Amherst, NY

Best Exit

Average Price

Highest

Entire Trip

Avg: $3.58

High: $4.10

Sheetz

Exit 187 Euclid, OH

$3.279

Speedway

Exit 186 Wickliffe, OH

$3.279

$3.58

$4.099

Ohio

Avg: $3.36

High: $4.30

Sheetz

Exit 187 Euclid, OH

$3.279

Speedway

Exit 186 Wickliffe, OH

$3.279

$3.36

$4.299

Pennsylvania

Avg: $3.80

High: $4.60

Sam's Club Gasoline

Exit 24 Erie, PA

$3.669

$3.80

$4.599

New York

Avg: $3.73

High: $5.70

BJ's Wholesale Club

Exit 56 Buffalo, NY

$3.529

$3.73

$5.699

Show Breakdown By State

Only searching fuel stations along supported Interstates, which make up 98.2% (193.0 of 196.5 miles) of this trip.

Order by: Driving
EXIT 187 90 OH-84; Bishop Rd Euclid, Ohio 1st Best Exit Sheetz Right (S) - 0.35 miles 28601 Chardon Rd, Wickliffe, OH 44092 $3.279 4 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.31
EXIT 186 90 US-20; Euclid Ave Wickliffe, Ohio 1st Best Exit Speedway Left (NE) - 0.97 miles 29201 Euclid Ave, Wickliffe, OH 44092 $3.279 4 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.31
EXIT 235 90 OH-84; OH-193; N Kingsville Kingsville, Ohio 3rd Best Exit Circle K Right (SW) - 0.1 miles 5569 State Route 193, Kingsville, OH 44048 $3.299 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.30
EXIT 183 90 E 222nd St Cleveland, Ohio 4th Best Exit Speedway Right (SE) - 0.86 miles 22251 Euclid Ave, Euclid, OH 44117 $3.349 5 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.47
EXIT 193 90 OH-306 S; Mentor; Kirtland Willoughby, Ohio 4th Best Exit Marathon Right (SE) - 0.08 miles 4189 State Route 306, Willoughby, OH 44094-9269 $3.349 4 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.37
EXIT 189 90 OH-91; Willoughby Hills; Willoughby Willoughby, Ohio 6th Best Exit Shell Left (N) - 0.58 miles 34802 Ridge Rd, Willoughby, OH 44094 $3.359 4 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.41
EXIT 212 90 OH-528; Madison; Thompson Madison, Ohio 6th Best Exit Marathon Right (S) - 0.14 miles 4393 Madison Rd, Madison, OH 44057 $3.359 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.36
EXIT 218 90 OH-534; Geneva Geneva, Ohio 6th Best Exit Getgo #3627 Left (N) - 0.15 miles 1759 S Broadway, Geneva, OH 44041 $3.359 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.38
EXIT 223 90 OH-45; Ashtabula Austinburg, Ohio 6th Best Exit Pilot Right (E) - 0.1 miles 2246 OH-45, Austinburg, OH 44010 $3.359 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.36
EXIT 241 90 OH-7; Conneaut; Andover Conneaut, Ohio 6th Best Exit Loves Right (SW) - 0.08 miles 2 Loves Dr, Conneaut, OH 44030 $3.359 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.36
EXIT 180B 90 E 152nd St Cleveland, Ohio 11th Best Exit WATERLOO GAS N GO Left (NE) - 0.25 miles 15222 Waterloo Rd, Cleveland, OH 44110 $3.399 >24h old 4 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.45
EXIT 184B 90 OH-175; E 260th St Euclid, Ohio 11th Best Exit Shell Right (SE) - 0.73 miles 26051 Euclid Ave, Euclid, OH 44132-3147 $3.399 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.53
EXIT 200 90 OH-44; Chardon; Painesville Painesville, Ohio 11th Best Exit Sheetz Right (S) - 0.79 miles 11090 Capital Pkwy, Painesville, OH 44077 $3.399 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.44
EXIT 195 90 OH-615; Center St Mentor, Ohio 14th Best Exit Marathon Left (NE) - 0.91 miles 8745 Johnnycake Ridge Rd, Mentor, OH 44060-6018 $3.459 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.46
EXIT 175 90 E 55th St; Marginal Rds Cleveland, Ohio 15th Best Exit Shell Right (S) - 0.4 miles 5505 Saint Clair Ave, Cleveland, OH 44103-1431 $3.499 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.50
EXIT 176 90 E 72nd St Cleveland, Ohio 15th Best Exit Sunoco Right (S) - 0.59 miles 6947 St. Clair Ave., Cleveland, OH 44103 $3.499 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.50
EXIT 178 90 Eddy Rd; Bratenahl Cleveland, Ohio 15th Best Exit Sunoco Right (S) - 0.67 miles 12307 Saint Clair Ave, Cleveland, OH 44108 $3.499 >24h old 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.50
EXIT 205 90 Vrooman Rd; US-86 S Painesville, Ohio 15th Best Exit Shell Right (SE) - 0.03 miles 6000 Vrooman Rd, Painesville, OH 44077 $3.499 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.50
EXIT 56 90 NY-179; Mile Strip Rd; Blasdell; Orchard Park Buffalo, New York 19th Best Exit BJ's Wholesale Club Right (E) - 0.13 miles 4366 Milestrip Rd, Buffalo, NY 14219 $3.529 6 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.64
EXIT 6 290 NY 240 (Harlem Road) / NY 324 (Sheridan Drive) Buffalo, New York 20th Best Exit Marathon Right (E) - 0.16 miles 4220 Sheridan Dr, Williamsville, NY 14221 $3.569 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.57
EXIT 182A 90 185th St Cleveland, Ohio 21st Best Exit Express Fuel Right (SW) - 0.05 miles 1150 E 185th St, Cleveland, OH 44119-2931 $3.579 5 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.62
EXIT 52E 90 Walden Avenue E; Cheektowaga Buffalo, New York 21st Best Exit Delta Sonic Right (E) - 0.6 miles 2285 Walden Ave, Buffalo, NY 14225 $3.579 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.59
EXIT 182B 90 E 200th St Cleveland, Ohio 23rd Best Exit Sunoco Left (N) - 0.86 miles 470 E 200th Street, Euclid, OH 44119 $3.599 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.60
EXIT 58 90 US-20 W; NY-5 W Irving, New York 23rd Best Exit Kwik Fill Left (W) - 0.21 miles Routes 5 & 20, Irving, NY 14081 $3.599 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.60
EXIT 52W 90 Walden Avenue W; Buffalo Buffalo, New York 23rd Best Exit Valero Left (W) - 0.98 miles 2437 Harlem Rd, Buffalo, NY 14225 $3.599 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.60
EXIT 7B 290 NY 5 (Main Street) Buffalo, New York 26th Best Exit Mobil Right (E) - 0.4 miles 5300 Main St, Williamsville, NY 14221 $3.639 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.67
EXIT 54 90 NY 400 Buffalo, New York 27th Best Exit Tops Left (S) - 0.97 miles 315 Orchard Park Rd, Buffalo, NY 14224 $3.659 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.69
EXIT 50A 90 Cleveland Dr Buffalo, New York 27th Best Exit Sunoco Right (E) - 0.21 miles 1030 Cleveland Dr, Cheektowaga, NY 14225 $3.659 4 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.67
EXIT 24 90 US-19; Peach St; Waterford Erie, Pennsylvania 29th Best Exit Sam's Club Gasoline Left (W) - 0.53 miles 7200 Peach St, Erie, PA 16509 $3.669 8 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.84
SERVICE PLAZA 90 Temporarily Closed - Angola Travel Plaza Angola, New York 30th Best Exit Sunoco Left (W) - 0.1 miles Milepost 447-E Angola Ebnd Plz, Angola, NY 14006 $3.689 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.69
EXIT 52A 90 William St; Buffalo; Cheektowaga Buffalo, New York 30th Best Exit Rusiniaks Service Right (NE) - 0.82 miles 2916 Union Rd, Cheektowaga, NY 14227 $3.689 >24h old 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.70
EXIT 27 90 PA-97; Waterford; State St Erie, Pennsylvania 32nd Best Exit Pilot Right (E) - 0.05 miles 8035 Perry Hwy, Erie, PA 16509 $3.699 5 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.73
EXIT 35 90 PA-531; Harborcreek; Phillipsville Erie, Pennsylvania 32nd Best Exit TA Travel Center Left (NW) - 0.03 miles 4050 Depot Rd, Erie, PA 16510 $3.699 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.70
EXIT 45 90 U.S. 20; State Line North East, Pennsylvania 32nd Best Exit Citgo Right (E) - 0.07 miles 12271 E Main Rd, North East, PA 16428 $3.699 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.78
EXIT 59 90 NY-60; Dunkirk; Fredonia Dunkirk, New York 32nd Best Exit Tops Left (W) - 0.19 miles 3955 Vineyard Dr, Dunkirk, NY 14048 $3.699 >24h old 4 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.70
EXIT 57A 90 Eden; Angola Derby, New York 32nd Best Exit Mobil Left (W) - 0.72 miles 8445 Southwestern Blvd, Angola, NY 14006 $3.699 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.70
EXIT 57 90 NY-75; Hamburg; E Aurora Hamburg, New York 32nd Best Exit Kwik Fill Right (SE) - 0.27 miles 5466 Camp Rd, Hamburg, NY 14075 $3.699 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.72
EXIT 7A 290 NY 5 (Main Street) Buffalo, New York 32nd Best Exit Sunoco Left (W) - 0.96 miles 4505 Main Street, Snyder, NY 14226 $3.699 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.70
EXIT 5B 290 NY 263 (Millersport Highway) Buffalo, New York 39th Best Exit Sunoco Right (N) - 0.33 miles 4641 Maple Rd, Amherst, NY 14226 $3.749 >24h old 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.75
EXIT 61 90 Shortman Rd; Ripley Ripley, New York 40th Best Exit Loves Right (S) - 0.08 miles 6201 Shortman Rd, Ripley, NY 14775 $3.759 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.76
EXIT 32 90 PA-430; PA-290; Wesleyville; Colt Station Erie, Pennsylvania 41st Best Exit Citgo Left (NW) - 0.15 miles 5866 Station Rd, Erie, PA 16510 $3.879 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.88
EXIT 18 90 Pennsylvania 832; Presque Isle; Sterrettania Fairview, Pennsylvania 42nd Best Exit Marathon Left (NE) - 0.07 miles 6355 Sterrettania Rd, Fairview, PA 16415 $3.899 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.90
EXIT 29 90 PA-8; Hammett; Parade St Erie, Pennsylvania 42nd Best Exit Citgo Left (NW) - 0.19 miles 5838 Wattsburg Rd, Erie, PA 16509 $3.899 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.90
EXIT 60 90 NY-394; Westfield; Mayville Westfield, New York 44th Best Exit Citgo Left (NW) - 0.24 miles 8246 Route 5, Westfield, NY 14787 $4.099 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.10

iExit says...

If possible, try to fill up in Ohio. On average, regular prices in Ohio are 38 cents cheaper than New York, 45 cents cheaper than Pennsylvania.

Worst

Best