The Best Mid Grade Gas Prices from Cleveland, OH to Amherst, NY

Best Exit

Average Price

Highest

Entire Trip

Avg: $4.06

High: $5.10

First American Tobacco

Exit 58 Irving, NY

$3.449

$4.06

$5.099

Ohio

Avg: $4.00

High: $4.90

Shell

Exit 178 Cleveland, OH

$3.809

$4.00

$4.899

Pennsylvania

Avg: $4.21

High: $5.39

Citgo

Exit 29 Erie, PA

$3.899

$4.21

$5.389

New York

Avg: $4.19

High: $6.00

First American Tobacco

Exit 58 Irving, NY

$3.449

$4.19

$5.999

Show Breakdown By State

Only searching fuel stations along supported Interstates, which make up 98.2% (193.0 of 196.5 miles) of this trip.

Order by: Driving
EXIT 58 90 US-20 W; NY-5 W Irving, New York 1st Best Exit First American Tobacco (NE) - 1.0 miles 11404 Erie Rd, Irving, NY 14081 $3.449 >24h old 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.45
EXIT 6 290 NY 240 (Harlem Road) / NY 324 (Sheridan Drive) Buffalo, New York 2nd Best Exit Marathon Right (E) - 0.16 miles 4220 Sheridan Dr, Williamsville, NY 14221 $3.569 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.57
EXIT 52E 90 Walden Avenue E; Cheektowaga Buffalo, New York 3rd Best Exit Jims Truck Plaza Right (E) - 0.28 miles 2115 Walden Avenue, Cheektowaga, NY 14225 $3.799 >24h old 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.87
EXIT 178 90 Eddy Rd; Bratenahl Cleveland, Ohio 4th Best Exit Shell Right (SW) - 0.78 miles 11005 Saint Clair Ave, Cleveland, OH 44108 $3.809 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.81
EXIT 218 90 OH-534; Geneva Geneva, Ohio 5th Best Exit Kwik Fill Right (E) - 0.06 miles 1640 Oh-534 S, Geneva, OH 44041 $3.839 >24h old 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.88
EXIT 57 90 NY-75; Hamburg; E Aurora Hamburg, New York 6th Best Exit Mobil Left (NW) - 0.46 miles 5073 Camp Rd, Hamburg, NY 14075 $3.859 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.88
EXIT 29 90 PA-8; Hammett; Parade St Erie, Pennsylvania 7th Best Exit Citgo Left (NW) - 0.19 miles 5838 Wattsburg Rd, Erie, PA 16509 $3.899 >24h old 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.90
EXIT 7A 290 NY 5 (Main Street) Buffalo, New York 7th Best Exit Valero Left (W) - 0.18 miles 4933 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14226 $3.899 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.95
EXIT 235 90 OH-84; OH-193; N Kingsville Kingsville, Ohio 9th Best Exit TA Travel Center Right (S) - 0.17 miles 5551 State Rte 193, Kingsville, OH 44048 $3.919 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.99
EXIT 59 90 NY-60; Dunkirk; Fredonia Dunkirk, New York 10th Best Exit Mobil Right (SW) - 0.96 miles 242 E Main St, Fredonia, NY 14063 $3.959 >24h old 4 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.99
EXIT 50A 90 Cleveland Dr Buffalo, New York 10th Best Exit Marathon Right (E) - 0.58 miles 771 Wehrle Dr, Cheektowaga, NY 14225 $3.959 >24h old 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.03
EXIT 7B 290 NY 5 (Main Street) Buffalo, New York 10th Best Exit Marathon Left (SE) - 0.83 miles 771 Wehrle Dr, Cheektowaga, NY 14225 $3.959 >24h old 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.98
EXIT 180A 90 E 140th St Cleveland, Ohio 13th Best Exit Shell Right (S) - 1.0 miles 14021 St Clair Ave, Cleveland, OH 44110-3502 $3.999 >24h old 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.00
EXIT 183 90 E 222nd St Cleveland, Ohio 13th Best Exit Sunoco (NE) - 0.45 miles 940 E 222nd St, Euclid, OH 44123 $3.999 >24h old 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.06
EXIT 212 90 OH-528; Madison; Thompson Madison, Ohio 13th Best Exit Loves Right (SE) - 0.16 miles 1601 Great Lakes Way, Madison, OH 44057 $3.999 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.00
EXIT 223 90 OH-45; Ashtabula Austinburg, Ohio 13th Best Exit Pilot Right (E) - 0.1 miles 2246 OH-45, Austinburg, OH 44010 $3.999 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.00
EXIT 241 90 OH-7; Conneaut; Andover Conneaut, Ohio 13th Best Exit Truck World Right (SE) - 0.15 miles 780 Sr-7, Conneaut, OH 44030 $3.999 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.01
EXIT 56 90 NY-179; Mile Strip Rd; Blasdell; Orchard Park Buffalo, New York 13th Best Exit Sunoco Right (NE) - 0.66 miles 4479 Lake Ave, Buffalo, NY 14219 $3.999 >24h old 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.06
EXIT 52A 90 William St; Buffalo; Cheektowaga Buffalo, New York 13th Best Exit Speedway Right (E) - 0.61 miles 2700 Union Rd, Cheektowaga, NY 14227 $3.999 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.00
SERVICE PLAZA 90 Temporarily Closed - Angola Travel Plaza Angola, New York 20th Best Exit Sunoco Left (W) - 0.1 miles Milepost 447-E Angola Ebnd Plz, Angola, NY 14006 $4.009 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.01
EXIT 189 90 OH-91; Willoughby Hills; Willoughby Willoughby, Ohio 21st Best Exit Sheetz Left (N) - 0.38 miles 6035 Som Center Rd, Willoughby, OH 44094 $4.059 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.07
EXIT 61 90 Shortman Rd; Ripley Ripley, New York 21st Best Exit Loves Right (S) - 0.08 miles 6201 Shortman Rd, Ripley, NY 14775 $4.059 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.06
EXIT 187 90 OH-84; Bishop Rd Euclid, Ohio 23rd Best Exit Sheetz Right (S) - 0.35 miles 28601 Chardon Rd, Wickliffe, OH 44092 $4.069 4 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.08
EXIT 186 90 US-20; Euclid Ave Wickliffe, Ohio 24th Best Exit Speedway Left (NE) - 0.97 miles 29201 Euclid Ave, Wickliffe, OH 44092 $4.079 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.09
EXIT 193 90 OH-306 S; Mentor; Kirtland Willoughby, Ohio 24th Best Exit Sheetz Right (E) - 0.07 miles 4145 Oh 306, Willoughby, OH 44094 $4.079 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.14
EXIT 175 90 E 55th St; Marginal Rds Cleveland, Ohio 26th Best Exit BP Right (S) - 0.49 miles 5510 Saint Clair Ave, Cleveland, OH 44103 $4.099 >24h old 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.10
EXIT 180B 90 E 152nd St Cleveland, Ohio 26th Best Exit BP Right (E) - 0.18 miles E 152 Nd, Cleveland, OH 44110 $4.099 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.10
EXIT 182A 90 185th St Cleveland, Ohio 26th Best Exit Express Fuel Right (SW) - 0.05 miles 1150 E 185th St, Cleveland, OH 44119-2931 $4.099 >24h old 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.12
EXIT 184B 90 OH-175; E 260th St Euclid, Ohio 26th Best Exit Shell Left (NE) - 0.23 miles 25911 N Lakeland Blvd, Euclid, OH 44132-2415 $4.099 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.15
EXIT 205 90 Vrooman Rd; US-86 S Painesville, Ohio 26th Best Exit Shell Right (SE) - 0.03 miles 6000 Vrooman Rd, Painesville, OH 44077 $4.099 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.10
EXIT 35 90 PA-531; Harborcreek; Phillipsville Erie, Pennsylvania 31st Best Exit TA Travel Center Left (NW) - 0.03 miles 4050 Depot Rd, Erie, PA 16510 $4.119 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.12
EXIT 200 90 OH-44; Chardon; Painesville Painesville, Ohio 32nd Best Exit BP Right (S) - 0.21 miles 7515 Auburn Rd, Painesville, OH 44077 $4.149 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.19
EXIT 27 90 PA-97; Waterford; State St Erie, Pennsylvania 33rd Best Exit Sheetz Right (SE) - 0.21 miles 8180 Perry Hwy, Erie, PA 16509 $4.159 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.21
EXIT 54 90 NY 400 Buffalo, New York 33rd Best Exit Marathon Left (SW) - 0.53 miles 2793 Seneca St, Buffalo, NY 14224 $4.159 >24h old 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.16
EXIT 24 90 US-19; Peach St; Waterford Erie, Pennsylvania 35th Best Exit Gulf Right (SE) - 0.43 miles 8228 Peach St, Erie, PA 16509-4717 $4.169 >24h old 6 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.23
EXIT 32 90 PA-430; PA-290; Wesleyville; Colt Station Erie, Pennsylvania 36th Best Exit Citgo Left (NW) - 0.15 miles 5866 Station Rd, Erie, PA 16510 $4.199 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.25
EXIT 18 90 Pennsylvania 832; Presque Isle; Sterrettania Fairview, Pennsylvania 37th Best Exit Marathon Left (NE) - 0.07 miles 6355 Sterrettania Rd, Fairview, PA 16415 $4.399 >24h old 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.40
EXIT 60 90 NY-394; Westfield; Mayville Westfield, New York 38th Best Exit Citgo Left (NW) - 0.24 miles 8246 Route 5, Westfield, NY 14787 $5.099 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $5.10

iExit says...

If possible, try to fill up in Ohio. On average, mid grade prices in Ohio are 19 cents cheaper than New York, 21 cents cheaper than Pennsylvania.

Worst

Best