The Best Premium Gas Prices from Paterson, NJ to Brookhaven, NY

Best Exit

Average Price

Highest

Entire Trip

Avg: $4.54

High: $5.99

Delta

Exit 71 Englewood, NJ

$3.459

$4.54

$5.989

New Jersey

Avg: $4.37

High: $6.00

Delta

Exit 71 Englewood, NJ

$3.459

$4.37

$5.999

New York

Avg: $4.57

High: $6.00

Shell

Exit 49N Melville, NY

$3.659

$4.57

$5.999

Show Breakdown By State

Only searching fuel stations along supported Interstates, which make up 91.7% (65.2 of 71.1 miles) of this trip.

Order by: Driving
EXIT 49N 495 NY-110 N; Broadhollow Rd; Huntington Melville, New York 3rd Best Exit Shell Left (N) - 0.87 miles 1010 Walt Whitman Rd, Melville, NY 11747-3006 $3.659 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $3.66
EXIT 63 80 New Jersey 17 N; Rochelle Park; Paramus Lodi, New Jersey 4th Best Exit Shell Left (E) - 0.09 miles 110 Essex St, Lodi, NJ 07644 $3.699 5 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.18
EXIT 65 80 Green St; Teterboro; S Huckensack Teterboro, New Jersey 5th Best Exit Costco Gasoline Right (SW) - 0.68 miles 2 Teterboro Landing Dr, Bergen County, NJ 07608 $3.959 4 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.41
EXIT 61 80 Garfield; Elmwood Park Elmwood Park, New Jersey 7th Best Exit Fuel 4 Left (N) - 0.2 miles 551 River Road, Elmwood Park, NJ 07407 $4.039 >24h old 4 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.29
EXIT 64 495 NY-112; Port Jefferson; Patchogue Medford, New York 8th Best Exit Sam's Club Gasoline Left (E) - 0.43 miles 2950 Horseblock Rd, Medford, NY 11763 $4.049 4 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.37
EXIT 66 80 Hudson St; Huckensack; Little Ferry South Hackensack, New Jersey 9th Best Exit WaWa Right (SE) - 0.38 miles 505 S River St, Hackensack, NJ 07601 $4.079 5 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.38
EXIT 62A 80 Saddle Brook; Saddle River Rd; Garden State Pkwy Saddle Brook, New Jersey 10th Best Exit Delta Left (NW) - 0.72 miles 390 Floral Ln, Saddle Brook, NJ 07663 $4.099 >24h old 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.20
EXIT 52 495 Commack Rd; Commack; County Rd 4; N Babylon Huntington Station, New York 10th Best Exit Costco Wholesale Left (E) - 0.75 miles 10 Garet Pl, Commack, NY 11725 $4.099 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.40
EXIT 56 495 Smithtown; Islip; NY-111 Hauppauge, New York 12th Best Exit Sunoco (E) - 0.59 miles 360 Wheeler Rd, Hauppauge, NY 11788 $4.139 >24h old 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.38
EXIT 55 495 Suffolk County 67; Motor Pkwy; Central Lslip Brentwood, New York 13th Best Exit QuickChek Left (W) - 0.45 miles 648 Motor Pkwy, Brentwood, NY 11717 $4.159 4 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.37
EXIT 40W 495 NY-25 W; Mineola Old Westbury, New York 14th Best Exit BJ's Wholesale Club Right (E) - 0.45 miles 6049 Brush Hollow Rd, Westbury, NY 11590 $4.189 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.33
EXIT 64 80 New Jersey 17 S; US 46 E; Hasbrouck Hts; Newark Hackensack, New Jersey 15th Best Exit QuickChek Right (W) - 0.47 miles 120 US-46, Lodi, NJ 07644 $4.219 5 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.59
EXIT 62B 80 Saddle Brook; Saddle River Rd; Garden State Pkwy Saddle Brook, New Jersey 16th Best Exit Delta Left (E) - 0.93 miles 104 W Passaic St, Maywood, NJ 07607 $4.239 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.47
EXIT 67 80 Bogota; Ridgefield Park Ridgefield Park, New Jersey 17th Best Exit Valero Left (NE) - 0.74 miles 330 Palisade Ave, Bogota, NJ 07603 $4.279 >24h old 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.28
EXIT 57 495 NY-454; Commack; Patchogue Hauppauge, New York 18th Best Exit Sunoco Right (E) - 0.08 miles 1340 Motor Pkwy, Hauppauge, NY 11788 $4.299 4 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.60
EXIT 53 495 Bay Shore; Kings Park; Sagtikos State Pkwy Huntington Station, New York 20th Best Exit Sunoco (E) - 0.97 miles 90 Motor Pkwy, Commack, NY 11725 $4.339 >24h old 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.47
EXIT 58B 80 Madison Ave; Paterson Paterson, New Jersey 23rd Best Exit BP Left (NE) - 0.32 miles 780 Market St, Paterson, NJ 07513 $4.359 >24h old 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.48
EXIT 60 495 Ronkonkoma Ave; Lake Ronkonkoma; Sayville Ronkonkoma, New York 23rd Best Exit Exxon Right (SE) - 0.04 miles 322 RONKONKOMA AVENUE, Ronkonkoma, NY 11779 $4.359 4 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.43
EXIT 41S 495 NY-106 S; NY-107 S; Hicksville Jericho, New York 25th Best Exit Mobil Right (SE) - 0.31 miles 285 N Broadway, Hicksville, NY 11801-2900 $4.379 4 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.39
EXIT 46 495 Sunnyside Blvd; Plainview Woodbury, New York 25th Best Exit Mobil Right (SW) - 0.41 miles 220 Manetto Hill Rd, Plainview, NY 11803-1304 $4.379 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.38
EXIT 41N 495 New York 106 N; New York 107 N; Oyster Bay Jericho, New York 27th Best Exit BP Right (S) - 0.36 miles 300 N Broadway, Hicksville, NY 11801 $4.399 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.83
EXIT 43 495 S Oyster Bay Rd; Syosset; Bethpage Syosset, New York 27th Best Exit BP (NE) - 1.0 miles 200 S Oyster Bay Rd, Syosset, NY 11791 $4.399 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.45
EXIT 58 495 Old Nichols Rd; Nesconset Islandia, New York 27th Best Exit Shell Right (E) - 0.07 miles 1111 Old Nichols Rd, Islandia, NY 11749 $4.399 >24h old 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.40
EXIT 61 495 Patchogue-Holbrook Rd; Patchogue; Holbrook; County Road 19 Holbrook, New York 27th Best Exit BP Right (E) - 0.04 miles 5106 Expressway Dr S, Holbrook, NY 11741 $4.399 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.45
EXIT 63 495 N Ocean Ave; Mount Sinai; Patchogue; County Rd 83 Holtsville, New York 27th Best Exit Amoco Right (E) - 0.09 miles 5556 Expressway Dr S, Holtsville, NY 11742 $4.399 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.50
EXIT 32 495 Little Neck Pkwy Little Neck, New York 33rd Best Exit BP Left (NW) - 0.74 miles 4 Northern Blvd, Great Neck, NY 11021 $4.439 5 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.56
EXIT 37 495 Willis Ave; Roslyn; Mineola Roslyn Heights, New York 34th Best Exit BP Right (S) - 0.47 miles 1175 Willis Ave, Albertson, NY 11507 $4.459 >24h old 6 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.94
EXIT 11 295 Hutchinson River Pkwy; Zerega Ave; Throgs Neck Bridge; Whitestone Bridge Bronx, New York 35th Best Exit Sunoco Left (N) - 0.73 miles 3305 E Tremont Ave, Bronx, NY 10461 $4.479 4 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.89
EXIT 58B 80 Madison Ave; Paterson Paterson, New Jersey 37th Best Exit Shell Left (N) - 0.65 miles 10 18th Ave, Paterson, NJ 07513-1408 $4.499 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.59
EXIT 62 495 Nicolls Rd; Blue Point; Stony Brook Holtsville, New York 37th Best Exit 7-Eleven Right (E) - 0.85 miles 984 Waverly Ave, Holtsville, NY 11742 $4.499 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.50
EXIT 33 495 Community Dr; Lakeville Rd Great Neck, New York 41st Best Exit Mobil Left (NW) - 0.61 miles 595 Northern Blvd, Great Neck, NY 11021-5103 $4.599 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.82
EXIT 9 295 Harding Ave; Pennyfield Ave Bronx, New York 43rd Best Exit Mobil Right (NW) - 0.23 miles 4147 Throggs Neck Expy, New York, NY 10465 $4.699 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.70
EXIT 39 495 Glen Cove Rd; Hempstead; Glen Cove Roslyn Heights, New York 44th Best Exit 76 Left (N) - 0.42 miles 90 Glen Cove Rd, Roslyn Heights, NY 11577 $4.759 >24h old 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $5.37
EXIT 48 495 Round Swamp Rd; Old Bethpage Plainview, New York 44th Best Exit Cumberland Farms Right (SE) - 0.08 miles 1610 Round Swamp Rd, Plainview, NY 11803 $4.759 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.76
EXIT 60 80 NJ-20 N; Hawthorne Paterson, New Jersey 46th Best Exit Exxon Left (N) - 0.14 miles 770 20th Ave, Paterson, NJ 07504 $4.899 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.90

iExit says...

If possible, try to fill up in New Jersey. On average, premium prices in New Jersey are 20 cents cheaper than New York.

Worst

Best