The Best Premium Gas Prices from Paterson, NJ to Amherst, NY

Best Exit

Average Price

Highest

Entire Trip

Avg: $4.48

High: $5.26

Delta

Exit 39 Denville, NJ

$3.399

$4.48

$5.259

New Jersey

Avg: $4.37

High: $6.00

Delta

Exit 39 Denville, NJ

$3.399

$4.37

$5.999

Pennsylvania

Avg: $4.54

High: $5.60

Sam's Club Gasoline

Exit 190 Scranton, PA

$4.129

$4.54

$5.599

New York

Avg: $4.58

High: $6.00

K And P Mart

Exit 3 Binghamton, NY

$4.099

Kwik Fill

Exit 40 Weedsport, NY

$4.099

$4.58

$5.999

Show Breakdown By State

Only searching fuel stations along supported Interstates, which make up 92.0% (347.3 of 377.5 miles) of this trip.

Order by: Driving
EXIT 39 80 US-46 E; NJ-53; Denville Denville, New Jersey 1st Best Exit Delta (NW) - 0.69 miles 270 Us Highway 46, Denville, NJ 07834 $3.399 >24h old 4 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.31
EXIT 53 80 New Jersey 23; US 46; Wayne; Butler; Verona Wayne, New Jersey 2nd Best Exit Costco Gasoline Left (S) - 0.83 miles 67 State Route 23, Wayne, NJ 07470 $3.789 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.22
EXIT 52 80 Lincoln Park; Fair Field; The Caldwells Fairfield, New Jersey 2nd Best Exit BJ's Wholesale Club Left (E) - 0.7 miles 300 Willowbrook Mall, Wayne, NJ 07470 $3.789 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.14
EXIT 34A 80 NJ-15 S; Wharton Wharton, New Jersey 4th Best Exit Costco Gasoline Left (SE) - 0.18 miles 315 Hwy 15 N, Wharton, NJ 07885 $3.959 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.24
EXIT 56 80 Squirrelwood Rd; W Paterson; Paterson Little Falls, New Jersey 5th Best Exit 76 Right (NE) - 0.21 miles 339 Mcbride Ave, Paterson, NJ 07501 $3.979 >24h old 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.32
EXIT 55A 80 Union Blvd; Little Falls Totowa, New Jersey 5th Best Exit Valero Left (SE) - 0.8 miles 1755 US Highway 46, Little Falls, NJ 07424 $3.979 >24h old 4 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.18
EXIT 28 80 US-46 E; NJ-10 E; Ledgewood; Lk Hopatcong Landing, New Jersey 7th Best Exit Topspeed Automotive Right (N) - 0.57 miles 146 Landing Rd, Landing, NJ 07850 $3.989 >24h old 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.29
EXIT 43 80 US-46; I-287; Morristown; Mahwah Parsippany, New Jersey 8th Best Exit Woroco Right (SW) - 0.54 miles 175 Parsippany Rd, Parsippany, NJ 07054 $4.039 >24h old 5 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.49
EXIT 34B 80 New Jersey 15 N; Jefferson; Sparta Wharton, New Jersey 9th Best Exit FUEL 15 Right (NW) - 0.83 miles 210 State Route 15 S, Wharton, NJ 07885 $4.059 >24h old 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.44
EXIT 3 81 Broad Ave Binghamton, New York 10th Best Exit K And P Mart Left (SE) - 0.35 miles 198 Robinson St, Binghamton, NY 13904 $4.099 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.33
EXIT 40 90 NY-34; Weedsport; Auburn Weedsport, New York 10th Best Exit Kwik Fill Left (S) - 0.64 miles 2695 Erie Dr, Weedsport, NY 13166 $4.099 >24h old 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.43
EXIT 190 81 Dickson City; Main Avenue; Johnson College Scranton, Pennsylvania 12th Best Exit Sam's Club Gasoline Left (W) - 0.51 miles 921 Viewmont Dr, Dickson City, PA 18519 $4.129 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.36
EXIT 53 80 New Jersey 23; US 46; Wayne; Butler; Verona Wayne, New Jersey 13th Best Exit Sunoco Left (NE) - 0.85 miles 60 Riverview Dr, Wayne, NJ 07470 $4.159 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.20
EXIT 55B 80 Union Blvd; Totowa Totowa, New Jersey 14th Best Exit Power Fuel Left (E) - 0.6 miles 941 Mcbride Ave, Little Falls, NJ 07424 $4.239 >24h old 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.27
EXIT 53 80 New Jersey 23; US 46; Wayne; Butler; Verona Wayne, New Jersey 14th Best Exit Us Gas Right (NW) - 0.65 miles 44 Greenwood Ave, Wayne, NJ 07470 $4.239 >24h old 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.24
EXIT 37 80 NJ-513; Hibernia; Rockaway Rockaway, New Jersey 14th Best Exit Gulf Left (SW) - 0.77 miles 1 W. Main St., Rockaway, NJ 07866 $4.239 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.42
EXIT 30 80 CR 615 Ledgewood, New Jersey 14th Best Exit QuickChek Right (NW) - 0.03 miles 9 Howard Blvd, Mount Arlington, NJ 07856 $4.239 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.53
EXIT 27B 80 NJ-183 N; Netcong Netcong, New Jersey 18th Best Exit Sinclair Right (NW) - 0.32 miles 10 Us Highway 46, Netcong, NJ 07857 $4.259 >24h old 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.38
EXIT 308 80 Stroudsburg East Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania 19th Best Exit Walmart Right (W) - 0.43 miles 355 Lincoln Ave, East Stroudsburg, PA 18301 $4.279 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.39
EXIT 47 80 US-46 W; Parsippany Parsippany, New Jersey 20th Best Exit Phillips 66 (W) - 0.15 miles 730 Us-46 West, Parsippany, NJ 07054 $4.299 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.30
EXIT 307 80 PA-191; Broad St Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania 20th Best Exit Valero Left (S) - 0.44 miles 201 Broad St, Stroudsburg, PA 18360 $4.299 >24h old 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.47
EXIT 305 80 US-209 BUS; Main St Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania 20th Best Exit Gas N Go Right (N) - 0.51 miles 933 N 9Th St, Stroudsburg, PA 18360 $4.299 >24h old 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.45
EXIT 41 90 NY-414; Waterloo Clyde Waterloo, New York 20th Best Exit Loves Left (SW) - 0.09 miles 1262 Rte 414, Waterloo, NY 13165 $4.299 4 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.40
EXIT 49 90 NY-78; Depew; Lockport Buffalo, New York 20th Best Exit Kwik Fill Left (S) - 0.77 miles 6439 Transit Rd, Depew, NY 14043 $4.299 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.40
EXIT 27A 80 US-206 S; Somerville Netcong, New Jersey 25th Best Exit QuickChek Left (S) - 0.29 miles 84 US-206, Flanders, NJ 07836 $4.319 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.32
EXIT 306 80 Dreher Ave Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania 26th Best Exit Turkey Hill Right (N) - 0.39 miles 220 N 9th St, Stroudsburg, PA 18360 $4.339 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.46
EXIT 6 81 US-11; NY-12; Nimmonsburg; Chenango Bridge Binghamton, New York 27th Best Exit Gulf Left (SW) - 0.57 miles 1065 Upper Front St, Binghamton, NY 13905 $4.359 4 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.51
EXIT 6 290 NY 240 (Harlem Road) / NY 324 (Sheridan Drive) Buffalo, New York 28th Best Exit Marathon Right (E) - 0.16 miles 4220 Sheridan Dr, Williamsville, NY 14221 $4.369 >24h old 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.37
EXIT 42B 80 US-46; Parsippany Parsippany, New Jersey 29th Best Exit 76 Right (NE) - 0.45 miles 3440 Route 46, Parsippany, NJ 07054 $4.399 >24h old 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.40
EXIT 2W 81 US-11; Industrial Park Kirkwood, New York 29th Best Exit Loves Right (NW) - 0.18 miles 2 Industrial Park Dr, Binghamton, NY 13904 $4.399 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.55
EXIT 7 690 NY 297 – Solvay, Fairgrounds Syracuse, New York 29th Best Exit Byrne Dairy Left (W) - 0.26 miles 590 Bridge St, Syracuse, NY 13209 $4.399 >24h old 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.40
EXIT 7A 290 NY 5 (Main Street) Buffalo, New York 32nd Best Exit Valero Left (W) - 0.18 miles 4933 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14226 $4.429 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.46
SERVICE PLAZA 90 Clarence Service Area Lancaster, New York 33rd Best Exit Sunoco Right (N) - 0.0 miles Mile 412 Nys Thruway, Clarence, NY 14031 $4.439 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.44
EXIT 7B 290 NY 5 (Main Street) Buffalo, New York 33rd Best Exit Mobil Right (E) - 0.4 miles 5300 Main St, Williamsville, NY 14221 $4.439 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.44
EXIT 302 80 State Route 611; Bartonsville Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania 35th Best Exit Giant #6455 (W) - 0.21 miles 3560 Rte 611, Bartonsville, PA 18321 $4.459 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.61
SERVICE PLAZA 90 Junius Ponds Travel Plaza Waterloo, New York 35th Best Exit Sunoco Right (N) - 0.0 miles Ny State Thruwy 323 W Bound, Waterloo, NY 13165 $4.459 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.46
EXIT 44 90 State 332; Canandaigua; Victor Victor, New York 35th Best Exit Exxon Left (S) - 0.36 miles 6180 Collett Rd, Farmington, NY 14425 $4.459 >24h old 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.46
REST AREA 90 Temporarily Closed - Ontario Service Center Le Roy, New York 35th Best Exit Sunoco Left (SE) - 0.0 miles 8700 Vallance Rd, Le Roy, NY 14482 $4.459 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.46
EXIT 42A 80 US-202; US-46; Parsippany; Morris Plains Parsippany, New Jersey 39th Best Exit BP Left (SW) - 0.94 miles 1195 Littleton Rd, Morris Plains, NJ 07950 $4.499 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.50
EXIT 19 80 County Rd 517; Hackettstown; Allamuchy; Andover Hackettstown, New Jersey 39th Best Exit Shell Right (NE) - 0.14 miles 1707 Rte 517, Hackettstown, NJ 07840 $4.499 >24h old 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.50
EXIT 4B 80 US-46 E; Columbia Columbia, New Jersey 39th Best Exit TA Travel Center (NW) - 0.41 miles 2 Simpson Rd, Knowlton, NJ 07832 $4.499 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.50
EXIT 5 81 US-11; Front St; Broome C C Binghamton, New York 39th Best Exit Speedway Left (NW) - 0.31 miles 704 Front St, Binghamton, NY 13905 $4.499 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.50
EXIT 7 81 US-11; Castle Creek Castle Creek, New York 39th Best Exit Mirabito Left (SW) - 0.22 miles 1166 Castle Creek Rd, Castle Creek, NY 13744 $4.499 >24h old 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.50
EXIT 10 81 New York 41; Cortland; McGraw McGraw, New York 39th Best Exit Speedway Left (W) - 0.32 miles 3798 Route 11, Mcgraw, NY 13101 $4.499 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.70
EXIT 11 81 NY-13; Cortland Cortland, New York 39th Best Exit Mobil Left (SW) - 0.16 miles 152 Clinton Ave, Cortland, NY 13045 $4.499 >24h old 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.50
EXIT 17 81 Exit Syracuse, New York 39th Best Exit Mobil Right (SE) - 0.82 miles 968 E Brighton Ave, Syracuse, NY 13205 $4.499 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.50
EXIT 18 81 Adams St; Harrison St Syracuse, New York 39th Best Exit Sunoco Left (W) - 0.45 miles 680 S. Salina Street, Syracuse, NY 13202 $4.499 >24h old 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.60
EXIT 42 90 NY-14; Geneva Lyons; Lyons Phelps, New York 39th Best Exit Mobil Left (SE) - 0.12 miles 1735 St Rt 14, Phelps, NY 14532 $4.499 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.50
EXIT 46 90 I-390 N; Rochester Rush, New York 39th Best Exit Speedway Left (W) - 0.73 miles 4900 W Henrietta Rd, Henrietta, NY 14467 $4.499 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.50
EXIT 48 90 NY-98; Batavia Batavia, New York 39th Best Exit Citgo Right (W) - 0.28 miles 8204 Park Rd, Batavia, NY 14020 $4.499 >24h old 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.50
EXIT 48A 90 NY-77; Pembroke; Medina Corfu, New York 39th Best Exit Speedway Left (SE) - 0.18 miles 8465 Alleghany Rd, Corfu, NY 14036 $4.499 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.51
EXIT 48 80 Montville; Pine Brook Pine Brook, New Jersey 52nd Best Exit Raceway Petroleum Left (S) - 0.25 miles 27 Route 46, Pine Brook, NJ 07058 $4.529 >24h old 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.56
EXIT 2 690 Jones Road Syracuse, New York 53rd Best Exit Citgo Right (NW) - 1.0 miles 7361 State Fair Blvd, Baldwinsville, NY 13027 $4.559 >24h old 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.56
SERVICE PLAZA 90 Warners Travel Plaza Warners, New York 54th Best Exit Mobil Right (N) - 0.0 miles 2670 Brickyard Rd, Warners, NY 13164 $4.579 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.58
EXIT 310 80 PA-611; Deleware; Water Gap Delaware Water Gap, Pennsylvania 55th Best Exit Sunoco Right (E) - 0.28 miles 88 Broad St, Delaware Water Gap, PA 18327 $4.599 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.65
EXIT 299 80 PA-715; Tannersville Tannersville, Pennsylvania 55th Best Exit Gas N Go Right (E) - 0.21 miles 2836 Pa-611, Tannersville, PA 18372 $4.599 >24h old 6 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.70
EXIT 194 81 US-11 N; US-6 W; PA-407 N Clarks Summit, Pennsylvania 55th Best Exit Valero Right (SE) - 0.59 miles Northern Blvd, Clarks Summit, PA 18411 $4.599 >24h old 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.60
EXIT 201 81 PA-438; E Benton Dalton, Pennsylvania 55th Best Exit Duchniks Auto Service Left (W) - 0.16 miles 204 Montdale Rd, Dalton, PA 18414 $4.599 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.60
EXIT 206 81 PA-374; Glenwood; Lenoxville Nicholson, Pennsylvania 55th Best Exit Sunoco Right (N) - 0.04 miles 3615 Route 374, Lenoxville, PA 18441 $4.599 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.60
EXIT 10 690 North Geddes Street Syracuse, New York 55th Best Exit Sunoco Left (S) - 0.16 miles 517-19 N Geddes St, Syracuse, NY 13204 $4.599 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.50
EXIT 43 90 State Route 21; Manchester; Palmyra Shortsville, New York 55th Best Exit Sunoco Left (S) - 0.13 miles 70 N Main St, Manchester, NY 14504 $4.599 >24h old 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.60
EXIT 199 81 PA-524; Scott Olyphant, Pennsylvania 62nd Best Exit Mobil Right (SE) - 0.03 miles 98 Hill Rd, Dalton, PA 18414 $4.649 >24h old 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.65
EXIT 188 81 Dunmore; Throop Scranton, Pennsylvania 63rd Best Exit Sunoco Right (NE) - 0.19 miles 1218 O'Neill Highway, Dunmore, PA 18512 $4.659 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.72
EXIT 230 81 WI-171; Great Bend; Susquehanna Great Bend, Pennsylvania 63rd Best Exit Citgo Right (E) - 0.03 miles Route 81 & State Route 171, Great Bend, PA 18821 $4.659 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.86
EXIT 4S 81 NY 7 Binghamton, New York 63rd Best Exit Citgo Left (W) - 1.0 miles 283 Front St, Binghamton, NY 13905 $4.659 >24h old 2 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.71
EXIT 9 81 NY-221; US-11; Marathon Marathon, New York 63rd Best Exit Valero Left (W) - 0.14 miles 28 Cortland St, Marathon, NY 13803-0123 $4.659 >24h old 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.66
EXIT 80 Starlite Hill Road;Hainesburg River Road Columbia, New Jersey 67th Best Exit Sunoco Left (SE) - 0.45 miles 17-19 Simpson Rd, Columbia, NJ 07832 $4.679 >24h old 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.68
EXIT 14 81 New York 80; Tully Tully, New York 67th Best Exit Circle K (N) - 0.1 miles 5755 Rte 80, Tully, NY 13159 $4.679 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.68
EXIT 309 80 US-209 N; PA-447 N; Marshalls Creek East Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania 69th Best Exit Gulf Right (NE) - 0.06 miles 834 Seven Bridge Rd, East Stroudsburg, PA 18301 $4.699 >24h old 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.70
EXIT 194 81 US-11 N; US-6 W; PA-407 N Clarks Summit, Pennsylvania 69th Best Exit Sheetz Right (NW) - 0.55 miles 1109 Northern Blvd, Clarks Summit, PA 18411 $4.699 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.70
SERVICE PLAZA 90 Seneca Travel Plaza Victor, New York 69th Best Exit Mobil Right (N) - 0.0 miles 7029 Aldridge Rd, Victor, NY 14564 $4.699 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.70
EXIT 1 81 US-11; NY-7; Kirkwood; Conklin Kirkwood, New York 72nd Best Exit Mirabito Left (SW) - 0.18 miles 1724 Us Route 11, Kirkwood, NY 13795 $4.739 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.74
EXIT 219 81 PA 848;T560 New Milford, Pennsylvania 73rd Best Exit Sunoco Right (E) - 0.03 miles 2174 PA-848, New Milford, PA 18834 $4.799 >24h old 3 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.87
EXIT 35A 80 Dover Wharton, New Jersey 74th Best Exit Exxon Left (S) - 0.59 miles 5 Mount Pleasant Ave, Dover, NJ 07801 $4.899 >24h old 1 prices within 1 mile - Avg: $4.90

iExit says...

If possible, try to fill up in New Jersey. On average, premium prices in New Jersey are 17 cents cheaper than Pennsylvania, 21 cents cheaper than New York.

Worst

Best